Housing disrepair refers to the deterioration of a property to the point where it becomes unsafe or unsuitable for tenants to live in. When tenants file disrepair claims, it’s often because critical aspects of their home—such as heating, plumbing, or structural integrity—are failing and require urgent attention. Under Section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, social housing providers have a legal obligation to investigate and resolve such issues, ensuring properties remain safe and habitable.
However, over the past 12 to 18 months, there has been a troubling increase in dishonest disrepair claims, driven largely by external actors such as solicitors and claim management firms. This surge in unjustified claims is placing significant strain on housing providers, diverting resources away from tenants with legitimate needs.
Solicitors and Their Role in Disrepair Claims
Solicitors play an important role in the housing disrepair process. They support tenants in navigating the legal system, ensuring valid claims are heard and appropriate remedies are secured. For tenants living in substandard conditions, this legal support can be invaluable, particularly when landlords fail to fulfil their obligations.
However, in recent years, some solicitors have exploited the system by encouraging tenants to file disrepair claims, even when the issues are minor or non-existent. This practice often involves targeting vulnerable tenants who may not fully understand their rights or the condition of their property. Solicitors operating on a “no win, no fee” basis have a financial incentive to pursue claims indiscriminately, as they receive a portion of any compensation awarded, along with their fees.
This behaviour contributes to the rising number of questionable claims, forcing housing providers to expend significant resources investigating and addressing cases that may lack merit.
Claim Farms: Exploiting the System
The rise of claim farms has further exacerbated the issue. These organisations aggressively market their services to tenants in social housing, often using misleading advertisements that promise large compensation payouts. They prey on low-income households, bombarding tenants with phone calls, emails, and text messages urging them to lodge disrepair claims, regardless of whether issues genuinely exist.
Previously focused on areas such as PPI and personal injury claims, claim farms have shifted to housing disrepair as a lucrative new market. The legal requirement for housing providers to investigate every claim makes this a low-risk, high-reward opportunity for such firms. However, the consequences for social housing providers—and for tenants with genuine concerns—are significant.
Tenants who might otherwise have resolved minor issues through routine maintenance channels are instead drawn into a complex legal process, which can delay repairs and cause unnecessary stress.
The Strain on Social Housing Providers
Social housing providers are legally bound to investigate all claims, even those that appear frivolous. While this safeguard protects tenants’ rights, the current volume of unsubstantiated claims is overwhelming housing organisations, creating several challenges:
1. Resource and Staffing Pressures
Investigating disrepair claims requires time, expertise, and manpower. With the increase in claims, staff are stretched thin, leaving fewer resources available to address genuine maintenance issues. This shift in priorities affects tenants who urgently need repairs and creates backlogs in routine housing management tasks.
2. Financial Impact
Unjustified claims come with significant financial costs. Providers must allocate funds to investigate each case and, in some instances, cover legal fees if claims escalate to court proceedings. These additional expenses strain already tight budgets, reducing the funds available for essential maintenance and long-term housing improvements.
3. Delays in Resolving Genuine Cases
As housing providers grapple with a surge in claims, tenants with legitimate disrepair issues may face longer waiting times for resolutions. This undermines trust between tenants and their landlords, as genuine concerns are deprioritised in favour of meeting legal obligations tied to false or exaggerated claims.
Moving Forward: Balancing Rights and Responsibilities
Housing disrepair laws are vital to protecting tenants’ rights and ensuring safe, habitable homes. However, the misuse of these laws by certain solicitors and claim farms threatens the integrity of the system. The rising tide of dishonest claims creates an unsustainable burden on housing providers and ultimately harms the very tenants the system is designed to protect.
To address this challenge, social housing providers and regulators must work together to:
Raise Awareness: Educate tenants about their rights and the appropriate channels for addressing housing issues.
Strengthen Regulation: Implement stricter controls on claim farming practices and introduce penalties for solicitors or organisations found to be abusing the system.
Streamline Investigations: Develop efficient processes for triaging and addressing claims, ensuring genuine cases are prioritised.
By taking these steps, the sector can restore balance, focusing resources on supporting tenants with genuine disrepair concerns while mitigating the impact of baseless claims.
How PM+ Can Help
At PM+, we understand the pressures that social housing providers face in managing disrepair claims. Our expert team specialises in conducting comprehensive disrepair surveys, helping you identify and resolve issues efficiently while maintaining compliance with legal obligations. With a proactive approach, we work with you to streamline processes, prioritise genuine cases, and protect your resources.
Let us support you in delivering the best outcomes for your tenants. Visit our Disrepair Surveys page to learn more about how PM+ can help, or contact us directly to discuss your needs. Together, we can tackle dishonest claims and keep your housing stock in the best possible condition.
Comments